Why Spanking Is Not Okay
Spanking isn’t good for any child. Pediatricians at Kaiser Permanente and the American Academy of Pediatrics agree – spanking is a poor way to discipline a child.
But parents often ask: Why not spank to teach a child right from wrong? If a parent was spanked themselves, it’s especially important to consider how that may affect their own coping and parenting style.
Here are some of the negative effects of spanking:
Spanking teaches aggression. I’ve always explained to parents that hitting a child shows them that physical aggression is an appropriate way to solve a problem. Does it make sense to spank Johnny if he takes a toy from his brother or bites a friend? It doesn’t. Parents are more likely to spank when a child has been aggressive. Yet studies show that kids who are disciplined with spanking are more likely to become increasingly aggressive.
Spanking can harm. It’s confusing for a child to be hit by a parent whom they trust and love. Often when children are acting out they’re trying to get more loving attention from their parents. Try having regular “time in” with your child to connect and give them that attention. Spanking is linked to child abuse, as well as mental illness, aggression, domestic partner violence, and drug and alcohol abuse later in life.
Spanking doesn’t work. Spanking may seem to work initially, but studies have shown this effect doesn’t last. Over time, spanking stops working to control a child’s behavior and can actually make it worse. Kids learn right from wrong better without the threat of physical punishment. They learn with a patient and connected approach.
What works instead?
There are effective ways to help children improve their behavior, including:
Dr. Michele Evans, a pediatrician and expert in child abuse, explained her approach to me. She recommends parents use “rhythm, regularity, and routine.” If children know what to expect, they’ll feel more secure and less likely to act out.
One way to do this is to help kids with transitions. For example, give a 5-, 3-, and 1-minute notice that the current activity is going to change. Say: “In 5 minutes it’s going to be time to clean up the toys and sit at the table for dinner.”
Parenting can be a frustrating business! At times you may lose your cool and spank or slap without planning to. If that happens, talk with your child later to explain how their behavior made you upset but that you know hitting them was not the right way to act. This apology can become a great time to model owning mistakes and “making things right.”
After raising 3 spirited kids, I’m well aware of how close to our limits kids can take us. And to control their behavior, they need limits of their own. These can be taught in many ways – but spanking is ineffective, harmful, and should not be one of them.
Disclaimer: If you have an emergency medical condition, call 911 or go to the nearest hospital. An emergency medical condition is any of the following: (1) a medical condition that manifests itself by acute symptoms of sufficient severity (including severe pain) such that you could reasonably expect the absence of immediate medical attention to result in serious jeopardy to your health or body functions or organs; (2) active labor when there isn't enough time for safe transfer to a Plan hospital (or designated hospital) before delivery, or if transfer poses a threat to your (or your unborn child's) health and safety, or (3) a mental disorder that manifests itself by acute symptoms of sufficient severity such that either you are an immediate danger to yourself or others, or you are not immediately able to provide for, or use, food, shelter, or clothing, due to the mental disorder. This information is not intended to diagnose health problems or to take the place of specific medical advice or care you receive from your physician or other health care professional. If you have persistent health problems, or if you have additional questions, please consult with your doctor. If you have questions or need more information about your medication, please speak to your pharmacist. Kaiser Permanente does not endorse the medications or products mentioned. Any trade names listed are for easy identification only.